The Disney Wish had me at the boarding announcement. They announced each family as we walked onto the ship, and I’ll admit, I loved our little moment. The girls got special sheets for their beds, too. Those were the little touches Disney got right, and there were plenty of bigger things we loved.
What Disney did well
The character meet-and-greets were a highlight. The lines were fairly short, and once it was our turn, the characters took their time with the girls. I appreciated getting to enjoy the moment without feeling like I needed to hustle everybody along. The live shows were great, and the girls loved the pools. There were some really cool touches at dinner, but if you ask where our family was happiest eating, it was up on deck with the casual food. Sometimes everybody just wants to eat and get back to the pool.
The kids’ club looked amazing. The girls voted no.
We toured the kids’ club before we left port, and Disney went all out on the décor. I could see why kids would be excited to go in. When Jenna asked to leave, though, they called us right away to pick her up. I appreciated being called, but I would’ve loved for someone to offer her another activity or help her find something she felt comfortable doing first. Once we picked her up, she refused to go back. Jessica stayed, but when we asked if she wanted to go again, we got a solid no from her, too. So much for that little stretch of grown-up time I had pictured.
Castaway Cay was our biggest miss
For our girls at 4 and 6, Castaway Cay felt like a beach with a water slide they weren’t ready for. The slide looked way too intense for them, and neither girl is big on swimming in the ocean. That left us with sand play for most of the morning, which started with a trip to the shop for a bucket and shovel. By lunchtime, the lines were confusing, and the staff seemed overwhelmed trying to manage them.
If we had a do-over, we’d stay on the ship and skip the island completely. The girls already loved the ship’s pools, and I would’ve happily traded that bucket-and-shovel run for more time there.
One add-on I’d buy again
The photo package. I highly recommend it, especially if you’re usually the mama taking the pictures. There’s something sweet about looking back at a family vacation and actually being in the family photos.
If we sailed with Disney again, I’d build our days around the pools, the live shows, and the characters, with plenty of casual meals on deck. Those were the parts we all enjoyed, and I’d give us more time for them the second time around.